Skip to main content

The Aging Inner Critic

 

old woman frowning, inner critic

A funny thing happened over the past decade. My inner critic got old.

The last time I really looked at my inner critic, about fifteen years ago, she looked like the identical twin of my high school art teacher. The one who told me that I didn’t have any artistic talent, thus crushing my dreams of becoming a fashion designer. But I looked my inner critic up the other day and discovered that witch got old!

She no longer appears as my high school art teacher but is a completely new character running around in my head messing with me.

She tells me her name is Maude and she’s an old woman of the most crotchety type. Her skin is creped and full of wrinkles, her hair is gray, she is short (like me) and thin (not like me, which, She points out, is because I over-indulge and She doesn’t).

She smells of camphor liniment and the peppermint candies she clicks against her teeth whenever someone (me) says or does something that She doesn’t think is “appropriate”. Tsk.

She wears sagging support hose, sensible shoes she bought at Clark’s thirty years ago, baby blue polyester pants, and thread-bare white blouses. Her cardigan is the color oatmeal. She’s a strong believer that women of a certain age should dress their age and stop dyeing their hair or wearing make-up. The phrase, “Like putting lipstick on a pig.” Is always on the tip of Her tongue, waiting to be unleashed.

She believes in frugality to the point of self-deprivation and that risk taking is for the young. She thinks writing books or making art is a waste of time and, frankly, a little embarrassing. (Who do I think I am anyway?) Please don’t get her started on the idea of memoir writing. She’ll seethe for hours and remind me that nothing very important really ever happened to me.

She makes the inner critics of my past look like pansies.

She claims to be there to protect me. She keeps me from being a red-headed, brash, old woman just like Milly*, the woman from the bus trip through Italy I took with my husband when I was in my early thirties. The woman we could hear talking in the breakfast room one morning as we exited the elevator. She was going on and on about how cold and awful Germans were, as we walked by a business man, legs crossed, snapping his German language newspaper in front of his face. With Maude on my side, I will never become the Milly of the group.

But at what cost? In saving me from becoming someone who embarrasses herself, is Maude also keeping me from being a hell of a lot of fun? (And Milly was FUN when she wasn’t being an ugly American.)

Is Maude keeping me from writing most days? Wearing the clothes I want to wear because I’m afraid I’ll look old and fat? Keeping me from doing unseemly things and encouraging me to bore myself (and likely others) to tears?

Those are the questions I am currently mulling over. Maude loved the pandemic because I was safe and sound inside my house. Other than the occasional Zoom call (when she would sit beside me and point out my double chin on the screen), she didn’t have to remind me to stay in line. But with every step I take back into the world, she’s eyeing me. Right now, she’s still in her rocking chair, knitting away, but I can see her sidelong glances, worried I’m going to start going back out into the world, dressed in a ridiculous outfit of plaid and florals mixed together, wearing perfume and red lipstick (at least I used to wear a mask to cover that up!). She knows her vacation is coming to end.

But I’ve named her now. I know the protection she offers, and I’ll take it into account, but I also know she can play things too safe. I’m ready to stand up to Maude and see what I can do.   

*Name changed.

How about you? Who's your inner critic? Describe them in the comments below. Tell me what they are keeping you from doing.

Comments

  1. My inner critic looks and sounds like my mother. Her voice is sharp and she does a lot of scowling. Some of the things she's keeping me from doing are similar to what you described. I'll look at clothes and hear, "You can't wear That. That's for someone younger/thinner/prettier than you."
    When it comes to my writing, she thinks what I write is silly, so without even critiquing my word choice or sentence structure, she's there with her wet blanket before I even sit down to write. I hadn't thought about that before now, so thanks for this thought-provoking post.
    I think I will do some writing and clothes shopping just to spite her. So there!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. One of my previous inner critics looked like a relative too! It happens!

      Delete
  2. This is interesting. I've never really personified my inner critic, it makes sense to do so to help us deal with the critic. I'm currently doing 12 week course of Julia Cameron's Artist's Way and I've managed to separate myself and the "little artist" in me, treating her as my own child. I love this approach, it teaches me to be kind to her when she makes bad art, which is often ��

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Artist's Way changed my life. I'm so glad you are working through it.

      Delete
  3. My inner critics pop in the guise of people I know and are based on what I am doing in the moment. So if I finding a big mess in the house my inner critic shows up as the person I know who would NEVER let her house get messy like that because she is disciplined, structured and routine-all things I am not an (according to my inner critic) the reason for anything unwanted that ever happens to me. If am short tempered or cranky she shows up at the smiling friend who never let anything get her upset and just let everything roll right off her back. You have really given me something to think about Laura thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  4. My inner critic is an old man. Not sure why that is. Maybe because my father was a perfectionist. The critic use to be my Crazy Maker (from the Artists Way) that was my husband and he was so critical and so stealth about it most of the time I never saw it coming. So this old man that might be my dad is always telling me it’s not perfect and I should just sit and color like a good little girl. He tells me that coloring outside the lines makes me a tramp and that is such a bad thing.
    So when I do go outside the lines I have such a fantastic feeling of creative expression and I get so lost in the art that critic just goes. Where? I don’t know and I don’t care. I just keep trying to go outside the lines so he can’t get to me.
    Thank you for your wonderful post. It really helps to make that critic a person. Makes it easier to deal with.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Inner critics are such an interesting thing to dig into aren't they?

      Delete
  5. Oh, this hit close to home! I love that you are ready to stand up to Maude and finding humor in her antics is one great way of doing that! If you can laugh at her, she'll go muttering away into her corner. The photo is so great as well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Michelle. I was looking for a photo to illustrate this post and came across this stock photo. It was like Maude was staring straight at me!

      Delete
  6. I'm glad you're standing up to Maude. Inner critics are such bullies. I guess haven't really paid much attention to mine. Well, at least I haven't named it. Something to think about. 🤔

    ReplyDelete
  7. How fun to name your inner critic. I've never personified mine, but now I'm thinking I might need to.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Garden Through the Years-June

This is our sixth year gardening. It's been a journey, every year we learn a little more. The garden has not only taught us how to grow plants, but also how to have patience and hope. It's taught me the healing power of nature. It has helped my husband and I grow our marriage through planning the garden and working side by side. It's inspired me creatively. Every year, I usually share a monthly update of my garden during the summer months. I'll continue the tradition this year, but I am also planning to share the garden's growth over the past six years. I'll show you what it looked like each month over the years. We started our garden in 2017, about 10 months after we moved to the Pacific Northwest.  My husband built our raised beds and we put up temporary fencing around the perimeter to keep the deer out. It was cumbersome to get in and out of the garden and it didn't deter the deer or the bunnies. They found a way in regardless. We grew tomatoes (too many)...

What I haven't told you

  I told you how I started making art, when a surprise pregnancy, at the height of my business career, propelled me into an identity crisis and I went in search of who I really was. I worked through The Artists Way , discovered a love of art in my past and built a new identity around that. I hung that idea high and called it my North Star. The stories I told around that idea supported it. I talked of my love of art and how my wicked art teacher took that dream, stomped on it, and sent me fleeing into the business world. But that is not the whole story. I didn’t leave out parts of my story to lie, I just brushed past them to connect with my creativity. I didn’t tell you about the literature classes I was taking in high school. Beloved teachers taught my literature classes and they opened the world of literary criticism for me. They most decidedly were not like my wicked art teacher, they supported and encouraged me. I didn’t tell you there were always stacks of books piled up ...

Famous First Lines

     W hen I was in college, I collected the first lines of books. I had a journal to hold my collection and, whenever I came across a particularly good first line, I wrote it down. My two favorites were the openings lines of Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s book, Love in the Time of Cholera: “It was inevitable: the scent of bitter almonds always reminded him of the fate of unrequited love.” and Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier : “Last night, I dreamt I went to Manderley again.”      I had these lines memorized and would trot them out during late night literary discussions with my fellow literature major friends. I cringe when I think of my younger self doing that, but you know she was on to something because now that I’m trying my hand at writing, I’m realizing that opening lines are my superpower. At least I know how to start story.      Recently, I read an article about Shirley Jackson’s opening paragraph to We Have Always Lived in the Cast...

The Seed Library

I am standing in front of the old, wooden card catalog of the Washougal Library and am reminded of the card catalogs of my past. The first was in my elementary school library where we learned how to look up books using the Dewey Decimal System. I remember the sound the drawers made as I slowly and carefully pulled them out-a quiet creak of wood in a silent library. Then the smell would fill the air. It was the smell of old paper and the typewriter ink the librarian used to carefully catalog the books.             Now, I look up my books on a computer but today I am, once again, standing in front of the card catalog. I pull out the drawer and am surprised that the sound and the smell are still there, even though I am standing in a library 2,455 miles away from the one in my memory. The drawer no longer holds cards listing a multitude of books to be read, instead it holds small packets of seeds.      ...

My Favorite Things

"If I dismiss the ordinary-waiting for the special, the extreme, the extraordinary to happen-I may just miss my life." -Laura Pashby Lately I've been reading Little Stories of Your Life: Find Your Voice, Share Your World, and Tell Your Story by Laura Pashby. It's so good! While I think the book's focus is on micro-blogging (aka Instagram posts), I'm finding so much inspiration for my longer form writing in it. The exercises are inspiring and I'm using them as writing prompts and ways to improve my photography. If you haven't read it, I  recommend you get it. One of the prompts is to make lists that you can later use for storytelling and I thought I would share one of my lists with you today-a list of my favorite things in my studio. While my whole house is filled with things I love, I typically save the most beloved things for my studio. It's where I curl-up to write and stitch so it's very important to me to fill the room with things that make...

Sketchbook Musings

       I sometimes wonder what my grandchildren will think if they flip through my sketchbooks?       When they pick-up my Botanical Wonder Sketchbook will they see that I was an avid gardener, deeply in love with nature? Will they marvel at my account of almanac-like posts and see a personal account of climate change?      When they flip through my Recipe Sketchbooks, they will see the Ambrosia recipe I wrote down and illustrated, based on my great-grandmother's recipe. Will they be inspired by notes on our family tradition Taco Nights? Or maybe they will already have Taco Nights and realize where the tradition started.      When they look at my Artist Sketchbooks, they will see that I designed a line of rubber stamps, based on my love of tea and gardens, and notes for some of my embroidery designs. Will they be inspired to learn how to embroider or explore their own creativity?      When they look at...

Using Photos as Writing Prompts

I was going to throw this photo away. I've been on a mission to cull my personal photo collection and this one was a candidate for the trash bin. One of the criteria for keeping a photograph is whether it will have any meaning to future generations and the cropped head of my mother in this photo would make it impossible for anyone else to identify the subject. But as I looked at the photo, mulling over it's fate, I began to notice that it contained multitudes of information about my childhood and sparked memories that I would one day want to write about. The trick was to sit with the photo long enough and focus not only on the person in the photo, but also the location. Once I began this process, I found I couldn't wait to get to my writing prompt notebook and start writing. Of course, this my childhood photo and, as a writer who is focusing on the memoir genre, it is loaded with topics for future essays but even a fiction writer could find inspiration through this process ...

What Lies Beneath

  Since I last wrote about my garden , a lot has happened. And a lot hasn’t happened. We went from a wet spring to a few sparse weeks of beautiful summer weather, and then roared into blistering heat. My garden, unable to contend with Mother Nature’s mood swings, had suffered. Between heat waves, I would wander into my garden and, instead of looking to see what was growing, I looked for destruction. Which crop failed this week? The beds, usually lush and beautiful, have big bare spots where the vegetables failed to grow. Our potato plants, which seemed to be the only crop that survived the wet spring, had dried and brown foliage, leaving me to wonder if my Irish blood somehow invited blight. While the garden withered so did we. Heat, illness, and general malaise made us wither almost as much as our garden. In the midst of this ennui, my husband and I trudged out to face our wilting, seemingly dead garden, ready to pull the dead plants, and to grieve over the failed plot. ...

Melting Reading Watching

Want to know the best way to bring on a heat wave? Blog about the lovely summer weather you are experiencing... Melting A week of heat is just breaking here and I've fallen back out of love with summer. I think I may need to move Iceland if I have any hope of truly embracing the season.  The good thing about being locked up in one's house for a week, fans carefully organized around oneself, air conditioning blasting, is that you get a lot of reading done. Since this is the year that I'm working on becoming a better writer, I've been reading more. I credit the fact that I can write to my insatiable reading habit. If you read any book about the art of writing, reading is usually touted as one of the ways to become a better writer. I patiently explain this concept to my husband and daughter whenever they find me in the middle of the day, draped over a couch, iced tea in hand, reading (instead of doing laundry or making their lunch). I'm working I announce. And I'...